Case File — Ohio Valley, Tristate Region

Under the
Sycamores

"Crimes, Cover-Ups, and Secrets in the Ohio Valley."

30–40 minper episode
Weeklynew episodes
IN · KY · OHcoverage area
▶ Listen on Spotify Support on Patreon
Core Mission

Beneath the canopy of the Ohio Valley lies a history of forgotten cases and untold truths — investigated by father-daughter hosts Jeremy and Kayla.

How we work

Every case is built on primary documents: FOIA files, court records, and incident reports — not sensational speculation. By combining structural data analysis with human-centered digital research, we investigate unresolved crimes, political corruption, and bizarre regional mysteries throughout Kentucky, Indiana, and Ohio.

Tone

Grounded, analytical, and persistent — a father-daughter partnership, respectful of the people at the center of every case, and objective about the institutions that failed them.

Who we cover

A compelling case is a compelling case, full stop. We choose cases because they deserve answers — not because the victim fits a demographic true crime has historically favored. Race, economic status, and sexual orientation have no bearing on whether a story gets told here.

Who's Behind the Mic

A father-daughter investigation, told from two angles.

Jeremy, co-host of Under the Sycamores

Jeremy

Co-Host & Lead Analyst

With over 12 years of experience as an engineering technician in civil construction, Jeremy brings a rigorous, data-driven approach to Under the Sycamores. Rather than coming from a traditional journalism background, he relies on mathematical logic, structural data analysis, and technical literacy to dissect case files. A lifelong Midwest resident with a deep familiarity with the region, Jeremy turned a passion for true crime into an objective search for answers—focusing on raw facts, documented timelines, and hard evidence over speculation.

Kayla, co-host of Under the Sycamores

Kayla

Co-Host & Digital Researcher

Born and raised in Kentucky, Kayla brings a compassionate, human-centered lens to Under the Sycamores. Currently studying cybersecurity, she combines digital investigative skills with a deep understanding of how modern cases unfold online. While analyzing raw data and official records is essential, Kayla ensures the show never loses sight of the human stories behind the files—focusing on victim advocacy, empathetic storytelling, and a fresh perspective on the Ohio Valley's cold cases.

The Blueprint

Every episode follows the same 35 minutes.

Standard episode
runtime · timestamped
00:00 – 02:00

The Cold Open

A gripping opening quote, detail, or piece of evidence — before any context is given.

02:00 – 04:00

Show Intro & Theme

Brief branding, disclaimers, and setup for the case ahead.

04:00 – 15:00

Act I — The Human Story & Mystery

The victim, the narrative timeline, and the core mystery, told before official involvement enters the picture.

15:00 – 25:00

Act II — The Systemic Failure

Law enforcement response, procedural errors, missing files, or political ties — examined directly.

25:00 – 32:00

Act III — Unanswered Questions

Local rumors, fact-checked against documented evidence.

32:00 – 35:00

Outro & Call to Action

Active tip-line details and how to access open records for the case.

Have Information?

Open records access and an active tip line run at the end of every episode.

If you know something about a case covered on the show, or you're a records custodian who can help fill in a gap — reach out directly.

Tip Line info@underthesycamores.org

All tips are treated as leads for further, document-based verification — not taken at face value.